We can all remember the feeling— sweaty palms, fidgety feet, hands clutching the podium with the desperation of a drowning man: the dreaded high school oral presentation. I have been spending time this semester with 11th graders at a local high school, and had the opportunity to watch these students present on political individuals who made a significant impact in the world, a spin-off on Profiles in Courage.
The students made many interesting choices, ranging from Maynard Jackson, the first black mayor of Atlanta, to Anna Politkovskaya, a world-renowned Russian journalist. Other students chose the predictable and school-worn names— Thomas Jefferson, Abraham Lincoln, Teddy Roosevelt, etc. I enjoyed watching these presentations and getting a sense of each student’s personality, but something was troubling me. Many students were laughing and speaking in sarcastic voices, which probably had something to do with nerves and self-consciousness, but they were giggling over the bravery of Harriet Tubman, the existence of American slavery in the past, the courage of social activist Rosa Parks (who was not just tired from a long day of shopping, as some textbooks claim). Why was battling social oppression and injustice funny? I wanted to say something, but as a mere observer in the classroom, it wasn’t really my place.
This situation still baffles me, but one thing I have gathered is that students have trouble making emotional connections to historical events, thus rendering the accomplishments of Tubman and others a bit meaningless in the minds of students. A classmate of mine suggested that perhaps the atrocities of slavery are so far removed from American society today, students have trouble comprehending. Stories of the past seem almost silly to them. I still don’t know whether this fully explains what I witnessed in the classroom, but it is something for teachers to consider. Does anyone else have any speculations on what was going on in that 11th grade classroom?
—Katie Harris
Recent Comments